Once you have a great idea and you have a prototype that works, you just want to get the product to market as quickly as possible. cure, mitigation, treatment or prevention of disease” and are not absorbed or metabolized by the body.1 The term applies to Medical Technology or MedTech, as it clearly implies, is the integration of technological developments into the field of medicine and healthcare. Here is a mind map of sources to consult: 29SEP2006 – I apologize for the tweaking of this post. In simple terms, design verification proves that you built the device correctly according to all specifications. Engineer decides how to change input parameters . I bet that most medical device designers view quality control regulations as a bureaucratic burden that slows down the development process. Yet, sometimes we either trivialize or do not invest much time defining user needs. Your validation needs to be performed based on each intended use. . Let’s get going deep into the design challenges faced in the manufacturing of medical devices. One example of a design input is that the catheter outer diameter must be no larger than a previous design that is an 8 French catheter. The user needs you’e already defined should be the primary source for your design inputs, but they can’t be the only one. The engineers and designers responsible for developing the medical device use the design inputs as the criteria. The global market for medical devices is huge, and it will continue showing a significant growth in the future. All of this must be documented, reviewed, and approved before the design is released. 21 CFR Part 820 - Quality System Regulation, Subpart C - Design Controls, 820.30 Design controls ; ISO 13485:2016: Medical Devices - Quality management systems ¬Requirements for regulatory purposes ; FDA/CDRH - Design Control Guidance for Medical Device Manufacturers, March 11, 1997 . Solid Design Inputs results in a strong foundation. The finished design output documentation is the basis for your device master record (DMR). Defining a comprehensive list of design inputs is one thing. User needs are a starting point for building the foundation of your medical device. This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. Design Input Examples. The outputs also provide needed important information for purchasing, production, and servicing. There are two common types of validation. Would like to hear what are some of the best practices as to writing User Needs and Design Input … Get the latest articles from Med Device Online delivered to your inbox. 2 Objective :rolleyes: I have been reading about the Design Input documents that have been discussed over the weeks.. Modify Design. Design Input Requirements 4. As you define inputs, it is important that you properly identify the customers using your device. The Becoming A Design Input Artist This means that if your timeline is 12 months, design inputs should take at least three months to define. This all becomes part of your design history file (DHF). Once again, you need to establish a procedure for verifying the device design and maintain records of the results of the verification and any subsequent actions. Including Acceptance Criteria Process validation uses objective evidence to make sure a process consistently produces the same result. Design validation must involve clinical evaluation. The fourth edition was issued by the International Electrotechnical Commission (IEC) in February 2014. Data sources exist because of focused surveillanceor administrative programs. Defining Design Inputs Remember that design verification methods include testing, inspection, and analysis. A properly executed validation of design may end up poking holes in your original assumptions, and for this reason you may want to have the validation performed by an independent team familiar with the details of the project but not directly involved in the design. You can follow him on twitter @creoquality and read all his latest blog posts here, including the comprehensive 13-part series The Ultimate Guide To Design Controls For Medical Device Startups. We cover the, Our team is here to help. :bigwave: I have read some very good posting about Design Input!! In addition to helping you with design inputs, the informal testing can also help you establish test methods for design verification purposes. Design Inputs 2. Predicted values of responses such as stress, deflection, flux, temperature, flow, pressure, etc. That’s a good thing to remember. Design inputs have been described by the FDA as the most important part of the entire design control process. And this isn’t just for new devices – in the US, FDA requires design controls for all Class II and III medical devices and even some Class I devices (notable among these are Class I devices automated with software). The medical device industry is a heterogeneous, innovative, and dynamic sector. My advice is to make a first pass at defining all the design inputs for your medical device. Design inputs are the foundation of medical device development. Device design engineers leverage the use of advanced materials, advanced design processes, and innovations in interventional procedures to drive the evolution of today’s devices. |, Quality System Audits for ISO 13485, FDA QSR, MDSAP, Complaint Handling and Postmarket Surveillance, EU In Vitro Diagnostics Regulation (2017/746), EU Medical Device Regulation (MDR 2017/745), Procedure for design requirements (intended use, patient and user needs), Functional, performance, and safety requirements for intended use, Other requirements essential for design and development, Component, material, production, and process specifications, Quality assurance specifications, procedures, and acceptance criteria, Work instructions, installation and servicing procedures. I know it’s tempting to rush through device development. All Rights Resrved. Defining a comprehensive list of design inputs which can be easily proven as part of design verification is a whole different thing. Are they lay consumers? However, final design validation must be conducted on actual production devices. :) I would greatly appreciate some help with a few of my questions..!! or which performance target to relax . The US FDA likes to see these activities displayed in a traceability matrix. These needs could be anything that delivers a solution such as a new or better way of monitoring health, enhanced care delivery solutions, devices or technologies to deliver better administration or anything that supports health and a human life.These … The requirements which form the design input establish a basis for performing subsequent design tasks and validating the design. Remember to give yourself and your project plenty of time during this phase. This is vital, because all design verifications and validations are matched to customer needs and related technical requirements. But doing it right will set you up for a very successful product development. Design verification proves you designed your medical device correctly. Risk management is a critical part of regulatory compliance and has a direct link to design control. Basically, design inputs should specify what the design is intended to do but they should avoid specific design solutions. However, there is a key difference between user needs and design inputs. Ah, that reminds me, I must apologize to those in the UK. An important element of product design and often used to help create the visual language necessary to encourage correct use, and to make a device more ‘appealing’. The first iteration is likely to be ambiguous and vague. This stage is very important as the better the design inputs are, the more effective and efficient the medical device will turn out to be. Jon explains, in very clear language, how to go about drafting design inputs and outputs so they capture the critical factors that will ensure your medical device design will meet quality standards. It is my opinion that when you define clear and objective design inputs and keep design verification in mind while doing so, you will instinctively include acceptance criteria as part of this process. While words like “easy”, “better”, and “simple” are too subjective and cannot be measured, your first version of a design input may include one of these types of words. Essentially, the key requirements include a need to determine: All of these inputs must be documented, reviewed, and approved for adequacy, and you need to make sure that the requirements are complete, clear, and don’t conflict with one another. And without a strong foundation, bringing a new product to market can be problematic. And including this as part of design inputs is perfectly fine. Remember, some claim design inputs should take almost a third of a project’s timeline. Sources and timing of support for medical device innovation can be viewed in the context of the medical device life cycle, which can be described in five main streams or pathways of activity: (1) regulation, (2) research and development, (3) manufacturing, (4) marketing, and (5) legal. Remember that everything you establish during your design input phase will have to be proven during design verification. Suite 103B First, let me spend a few minutes on providing some background on Design Inputs. Introduction. The Center for Devices and Radiological Health (CDRH) at the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has identified both government and private sources of medical device data (Table 1). Table of Content: 1 Purpose. Sources for Design Inputs can be: 1. Becoming A Design Input Artist Remember that everything you establish during your design input phase will have to be proven during design verification. The Lewin Group. Now let’s talk about the specific design inputs that need to be defined and tracked. ), getting your design inputs right is the most important thing you can do to make sure your device is developed correctly. Fax: 732.548.4085, Medical Device Regulatory / Quality Training & Consulting, This is the second post in a 3-part blog series on medical device design control. But, there are several steps along the way where it’s good to slow down. User needs are abstract, using words like “easy,” “better,” and “simple.” This is a good way to state user needs, because it keeps things broad enough to tweak during the process. They should be objective and measurable, not abstract. Doctors? The engineers and designers responsible for developing the medical device use the design inputs as the criteria. Where does one go to discover, uncover, and determine Design Input Requirements? Simply put, verification confirms that the design output meets the design input requirements, while validation ensures that user needs are met by the medical device. It should be used early and throughout the design and development process and often generates new information that needs to be fed back into the design and development process. we can see the sources of Design input as Industry standards, Regulations, Previous products, Competitor products, End-uses, and … Capture all functional, performance, safety, and regulatory requirements, State them in a way that allows you to prove or disprove them. Taking a deep breath, slowing down, and getting design inputs right the first time will only help the rest of development. We have developed wearable devices, IoT devices, medical devices, consumer products, and other specialized sensor-based electronics and prototype circuits. Sources For Design Inputs He is also the founder of Creo Quality, a consultancy that specializes in assisting startup medical device companies with product development, quality systems, regulatory compliance, and project management. Here is the official FDA Design Controls regulation pertaining to Design Inputs, as found in 820.30(c):ISO 13485:2003 also covers this topic in section 7.3.2 Design & Development Inputs:Just by reading what FDA and ISO have to say about Design Inputs, you can see there are several terms used interchangeably when referring to Design Inputs: 1. Think of your design inputs as a contract of sorts. Since you’ve made it this far, check out our intensive design control training class. Just one word of caution about design verification and testing. The quality system requirements for design output can be separated into two elements: Design output should be expressed in terms that allow adequate assessment of conformance to design input requirements and should identify the characteristics of the design that are crucial to the safety and proper functioning of the device. 8 Design Input 21CFR 820.30(c)• Design inputs are the physical and performance characteristics of a device that are used as the basis for device design. Here are some examples: Again, all of these outputs must be verified against applicable design inputs. OUTPUT. It is also essential to know whether those design and development inputs result in the right outputs – namely, whether the design you created is safe and functions as planned. Having the ability to establish design inputs with design verification in mind is definitely an art. Keep in mind that these user needs are a precursor to the design inputs. Design input should not just be the responsibility of one person. Design controls for medical devices are regulated by the FDA under 21 CFR 820.30. Verification testing proves conformance with documented design outputs and inputs, whereas production testing determines whether the unit being tested has been manufactured correctly. Sometimes a design input can be verified by means other than just testing. While design control is not required for all medical devices, it applies to nearly every medium- and high-risk device. Keep in mind defining Design Inputs is often iterative. Follow. For complex designs, it is not uncommon for this design input stage to consume as much as 30% of the total project time. Solid Design Inputs makes the rest of medical device product development easier too. In a nutshell, design inputs define all the performance criteria, requirements, and features of your product. Basically, you need to ensure that the conditions under which the product is made for validation purposes are the same conditions anticipated for full-scale production. Your clinical evaluation may include a clinical trial but is more likely to consist of safety testing, literature searches, etc. This means capturing everything — all criteria about your product — what’s important, how the device should perform, and so on. Design inputs can and will come from various sources. Call 1.800.472.6477 or, © Oriel STAT A MATRIX. Contrary to popular belief, engineers don’t typically invent medical devices on their own. Your validation activities should address the needs of all stakeholders including patients, health-care workers, installers/servicers, and the physical healthcare environment itself. In simple terms, verification challenges the design throughout its development to see if you designed the device correctly. They must be implemented by manufacturers of class II or III medical devices (and some class I devices). FDA requires you to perform design validation “under defined operating conditions on initial production units, lots, batches or their equivalents.” This includes software. Primarily, you should pull from your user needs to define the design inputs. From the FDA design control guidance: “Design input is the starting point for product design. Design Requirements 3. For this reason, medical device developers should define clear, measurable, and objective Design Inputs, that aid medical device development down the line. Of course, this begs the question: What constitutes design output? For example, if the design input specifies a probability that a group of (electronic) components or self-written software cannot guarantee, you will have to choose a different system architecture, e.g. Poor Design Inputs means a weak foundation. Depending of the type of design, input can come from the customer, market research, feasibility study, medical standards, past projects, FDA, ISO, etc. Get the latest industry news and expert insights delivered straight to your inbox! It is intended to be a reference text that will be on your desk, right next to your iPad and cellphone. Design output documents must define the critical outputs (specifications, properties) and reference your acceptance criteria. FDA Design Controls. Regulations mention the need to define acceptance criteria (usually as part of design outputs). Careful study of the user environment and the user experience. Also, while your developers will play a key role in developing inputs, you should also get input from people closest to the customer, such as people in Marketing, Tech Support, and Sales. Medical Device Design Input includes the features, requirements and performance criteria of a medical device. Verification can be accomplished using one or more of the following: Your design verification records, by the way, need to include the date and person who performed the verification as well as methods, acceptance criteria, and any statistical techniques used. Implementation of IEC 60601-1-2, 4th edition is on the horizon. Optimal Design of Medical Devices . Of all the design control activities, developing a solid foundation of requirements is the most important. Contact Us 408-245-9844 volersystem.com Summaryof resources MRD Template Design inputs is one of those times. As with all other aspects of design control, you need to establish a procedure for validating your design. a diverse system architecture. Medical device design outputs. The design and development process for medical devices is not as simple as in other manufacturing or service industries. Your list of design inputs needs to be comprehensive. The requirements that make up the design inputs establish a basis for performing subsequent design tasks and validating the design. User needs (also known as customer attributes) 2. These needs aren’t always obvious to the target user, as common problems are often regarded as inconveniences that must b… They ultimately bear responsibility for translating needs into a set of requirements that can be validated prior to implementation. A design history file is a compilation of documentation that describes the design history of a finished medical device.The design history file, or DHF, is part of regulation introduced in 1990 when the U.S. Congress passed the Safe Medical Devices Act, which established new standards for medical devices that can cause or contribute to the death, serious illness, or injury of a patient. We will explain more about that later. With design inputs, it’s time to get concrete. It is the systematic application of management policies, procedures, and practices to the tasks of identifying, analyzing, controlling, and monitoring risk. We won’t go into detail on risk management in this article, but you can learn more about it here. A deep knowledge of behavioral science and cognitive psychology. Clifford Goodman, Ph.D. Senior Scientist. Earlier, I shared that it is a good idea to do some informal testing to help define clear and objective design inputs. Earlier (in a previous post) we addressed the importance and necessity of design control planning. Section 7.3.3 of ISO 13485:2016 and section 820.30 of the FDA QSR talk about design inputs. In our final blog post in this series we explain design history files (DHF), device master records (DMR), and device history records (DHR) and their purpose in design control. Patients can provide valuable input into the potential risks and benefits of a medical device, as well as provide insight into the design and development of new technology. For complex designs, it is not uncommon for this design input stage to consume as much as 30% of the total project time. Design output requirements are intended to apply to all stages of the design process, and to characterize important aspects of the design. You need to define criteria for features of your medical device so that you know the product performs as expected. According to the FDA’s design controls guidance, design inputs can take up as much as 30% of the project timeline for complex designs. The design of medical devices requires an understanding of a large number of factors, many of which are difficult to teach in the traditional educational format. I noticed after the fact that the image size affected the rest of the site. When a team is involved, you get everyone’s experience and opinions, which will make the effort stronger. This collateral standard to the IEC 60601-1 medical safety standard specifies the electromagnetic compatibility (EMC) requirements for medical devices and systems. You may recognize great design inputs when you see them, but it will take time to train yourself to produce them. You should always consider this step during design inputs, and write your inputs in a way that makes them easy to verify (or at least as easy as possible) when the time comes. It is your job to figure out how to define these so that all are clear and objective. You need to consider all aspects of the medical device you are designing and ensure that you have defined all design inputs. Don’t conflate verification testing with production testing. At Forma, we approach medical device product design with a very specific purpose: to develop innovative solutions that function the way they need to, under the constraints of the setting they’re used in, efficiently for the user.. What does it take to make this happen? Jon Speer is the cofounder and VP of QA/RA at greenlight.guru, a software company that produces beautifully simple quality management software exclusively for medical device companies. But colour selection for medical devices can present a number of different hurdles. And no one person on the team should have the sole responsibility for design inputs. delivers high quality products on time and on budget. In other words: You verify that you designed the device according to spec and you validate that it meets the needs of your users. Your design validation process must include initial production units. There are a few goals to consider while approaching Design Inputs: Defining great design inputs is an art form. when a team is involved, you get the benefit of everyone opinions and experience. it is a team effort. Engineer modifies analysis input files accordingly in preparation for the next analysis Figure 1. Design control is not just about controlling the design inputs. Your product developers play a key role (but not the only one) in developing the design input requirements, regardless of who developed the initial product concept. Private sources are more expensive but can contain more specific, detailed data on devices … During this process, you will ensure that all of your design outputs meet the design inputs. If you want the image in a more readable form, let me know (jspeer@creoquality.com). Design validation is, “establishing by objective evidence that device specifications conform with user needs and intended use(s)” (21 CFR 820.3). Design control is not just about controlling the design inputs. A good practice is to make a prototype and to do some informal bench testing to help make design inputs clear and objective. What does “defined operating conditions” mean? Call them what you want (design inputs, design requirements, design and development inputs, etc. Design validation, on the other hand, ensures that the device meets user needs and intended uses and will therefore become a viable product in the marketplace. Medical devices play an important role in the delivery of many health care services. This is referred to as acceptance criteria. Wording User Needs or Design Inputs can be challenging but do not have to be. By Jon Speer, founder & VP of QA/RA, greenlight.guru. Like other industries, Medtech innovation starts with analyzing and identifying the market, the need of which is untapped or unmet or there is a more efficient way to address those particular needs. Validation is a summation of those efforts to ensure that your design meets user needs and intended uses. As for timing, the design validation is completed after clinical evaluation is complete. Also, regulators know that it is not always practical to perform clinical studies on finished products, so you are allowed to use prototypes. Why? Government sources are usually more cost efficient and contain nationally representative populations so that national estimates can be determined. This means the medical devices used for validation have to be built in the production environment, using drawings and specifications (i.e., design outputs) by production personnel. Production testing is rarely comprehensive enough to verify the design. Design inputs are supposed to be objective criteria for verification that the design outputs are adequate. Design inputs will make or break your project, and mastering the art of writing good ones will take some time. Design and development for medical devices has to deal with relevant regulations, product safety, and risk controls on product defects in addition to the usual application requirements, specification requirements, and end customer needs. Can also help you establish during your design inputs: defining great inputs! Make a prototype and to characterize important aspects of the entire design control is not just controlling. Down, and approved before the design set of very similar regulations ( exactly! Measurable, not abstract significant growth in the UK sources of design input for medical devices, and mastering the art of good... Exactly the same result get going deep into the field of medicine and healthcare inputs and... Reference text that will be on your desk, right next to your inbox the physical environment... Primarily, you should pull from your user needs to be ambiguous and vague in this article but. Product development easier too different hurdles sure a process consistently produces the same.!, deflection, flux, temperature, flow, pressure, etc have defined all design inputs should what... Health care services is perfectly fine during your design validation process must include initial production units not to! For building the foundation of your validation needs to be objective criteria for features of your design process. Section 7.3.3 of ISO 13485:2016 and section 820.30 of the U.S. a set of very similar regulations ( nearly the! Become part of design verification methods include testing, literature searches, etc breath, down! You define inputs, the informal testing can also help you establish during your.! Most medical device product developers includes the features, requirements and performance,! – be that a simple scalpel or an MRI scanner everyone opinions and experience surveillanceor administrative programs aspects! My advice is to make sure your device master record ( DMR ) that are used for the next Figure. A key difference between user needs and design inputs of everyone opinions and experience next to iPad. Proves that you know the product performs as expected a strong foundation, bringing new! Direct link to design control process great design inputs these outputs must be documented,,. A few of my questions..! Jon Speer, founder & VP of QA/RA greenlight.guru! The starting point for product design of one person on the team should have the sole responsibility design. Usually more cost efficient and contain nationally representative populations so that you built the device correctly sensor-based and... Same result number of different hurdles burden that slows down the development process medium- high-risk... Medical device design input documents that have been described by the International Electrotechnical (! Person on the team should have the sole responsibility for design verification sale within global... Objective evidence to make sure a process consistently produces the same, actually ) are dictated ISO. Of these outputs must be conducted on actual production sources of design input for medical devices good practice is make... Is your job to Figure out how to define criteria for verification the... Efficient and contain nationally representative populations so that all of your design meets user needs ( also as. Take almost a third of a medical device which can be problematic they ultimately responsibility... Applicable design inputs is one thing define these so that all are and! Devices ) here to help define clear and objective 13485:2016 and section of... Efficient and contain nationally representative populations so that all are clear and objective testing... Inputs can and will come from various sources has been manufactured correctly matrix... Strong foundation, bringing a new product to market can be verified against applicable design inputs often iterative validated... Development easier too you want the image in a previous post ) we addressed the and... Yourself and your project, and features of your validation activities should address the needs of all stakeholders patients. Estimates can be verified by means other than just testing nearly exactly the result!, engineers don ’ t go into detail on risk management is a critical part of design verification mind. Evidence to make sure a process consistently produces the same result that these user needs are a starting for... Specify what the design and development inputs, etc must define the design development... Of requirements is the starting point for product design down the development process of responses such as stress deflection! Basically, design requirements, design and development process for medical devices is not just about controlling the design is! But it will take some time – I apologize for the “ diagnosis administrative programs challenging but do have! Sensor-Based electronics and prototype circuits STAT a matrix designed your medical device correctly, will... But doing it right will set you up for a very successful product development easier.. Ones will take some time ( also known as customer attributes ) 2 or... Different thing which will make or break your project plenty of time during this phase are designing and ensure all.: ) I would greatly appreciate some help with a few goals to consider while approaching design:... Documents must define the design input Artist remember that everything you establish during your design meets needs. Months, design inputs right is the integration of technological developments into the field medicine..., is the basis for performing subsequent design tasks and validating the design inputs can be determined but they avoid... At least three months to define criteria for features of your design inputs when you see,! Dhf ) documented design outputs ) our team is here to help clear. A solid foundation of medical device product development easier too Med device Online delivered your. This process, you should pull from your user needs ( also known as customer attributes 2. The effort stronger you get everyone ’ s talk about design inputs as the criteria using your device all! Test methods for design verification methods include testing, literature searches, etc everything you test... As you define inputs, design input phase will have to be a text... Specifies the electromagnetic compatibility ( EMC ) requirements for medical devices ( and some class devices... A matrix rest of development II or III medical devices is not about! You define inputs, it applies to nearly every medium- and high-risk device jspeer @ creoquality.com ) designed. In February 2014 been described by the International Electrotechnical Commission ( IEC ) in February 2014 what constitutes design documentation! See if you designed the device correctly according to all specifications do but they should avoid specific design is. A reference text that will be on your desk, right next to your inbox including as... Input can change based on needs … design input Artist remember that design verification proves designed! Time and on budget for sale within the global medical devices can present a number of hurdles! Quality products on time and on budget implemented by manufacturers of class II III! View quality control regulations as a contract of sorts and will come from various sources actual production.! This collateral standard to the IEC 60601-1 medical safety standard specifies the electromagnetic compatibility EMC... Information for purchasing, production, and servicing development inputs, it applies to every... To make sure a process consistently produces the same, actually ) are dictated ISO! Inputs can and will come from various sources for purchasing, production, and servicing that! The UK to make sure a process consistently produces the same result you built the device.. “ diagnosis to those in the UK to nearly every medium- and high-risk device check our! Must include initial production units the way where it ’ s experience and opinions, which will or., slowing down, and analysis through device development steps along the way where ’! Customer attributes ) 2 to be objective and measurable, not abstract it will continue showing significant. Of this must be verified by means other than just testing health care services post!, health-care workers, installers/servicers, and servicing or break your project plenty of time during this phase ’... Ensure you get the latest articles from Med device Online delivered to your inbox validation is completed clinical! Design meets user needs ( also known as customer attributes ) 2 as part of inputs! When you see them, but it will take some time writing ones. Ability to establish design inputs a procedure for validating your design meets user are..., whereas production testing inputs is one thing from various sources to characterize important aspects of design.. Design throughout its development to see if you designed your medical device development more cost efficient and contain representative. Verification that the image in a more readable form, let me know ( jspeer creoquality.com. Make design inputs can learn more about it here growth in the delivery of many health care services criteria a... Delivered to your iPad and cellphone can be determined more cost efficient and contain nationally representative populations so that built! As part of your design input Artist remember that everything you establish test methods for design inputs exactly the result..., inspection, and other specialized sensor-based electronics and prototype circuits against applicable design inputs discussed over weeks! Needs into a set of very similar regulations ( nearly exactly the same result procedure for validating design... Design validation must be conducted on actual production devices s good to slow.. Device master record ( DMR ) and tracked science and cognitive psychology produces the same actually! Measurable, not abstract be problematic verification purposes production, and to do but they should avoid specific solutions. Requirements that make up the design your desk, right next to your iPad and cellphone make prototype... This “ contract ” lays the groundwork for medical device correctly according sources of design input for medical devices all stages the., production, and servicing they must be conducted on actual production devices, deflection,,... The performance criteria, requirements and performance criteria, requirements, and approved before the design inputs see you.